What Makes a Property a Good Rental?
- Matt Tate
- Nov 28, 2025
- 3 min read
Not all properties make great rentals. Just because a home is beautiful or expensive does not mean it will perform well as an investment. The best rental properties are practical, low maintenance, and appeal to the needs of tenants in the area.
Whether you are assessing a new purchase or reviewing your current portfolio, here are the key things that make a property a strong rental performer.
Location and Amenities
Location is always a top factor. A good rental property is close to public transport, schools, shops, and local employment hubs. Tenants are looking for convenience and lifestyle. If a property is walkable, well connected, and situated in a desirable neighbourhood, it will likely attract more interest and rent quickly.
Also consider safety, school zones, and the overall condition of the surrounding properties. These details influence both rental value and long term tenant satisfaction.
Layout and Size
A practical layout is more important than a fancy one. Properties with good natural light, generous storage, and functional living spaces appeal to a wider range of tenants.
The number of bedrooms and bathrooms should match what is common in the area. A three bedroom home with one bathroom might be fine in some suburbs but limiting in others. Small outdoor areas are often preferred to large lawns that need maintaining. Think about who the likely tenants are and how well the layout will suit their lifestyle.
Condition and Presentation
Tenants want a property that is clean, safe, and in good working order. Well maintained homes attract better tenants and spend less time sitting empty between tenancies.
Presentation matters. Neutral décor, tidy grounds, and updated kitchens or bathrooms (even small upgrades) can make a big difference to first impressions. Avoid overcapitalising, but do invest where it adds value and reduces maintenance issues down the track.
Rental Yield
Rental yield is the return generated compared to the purchase price. A high value property may look great but could have a relatively low yield if the weekly rent is not strong enough.
Investors should balance the potential for capital growth with a yield that covers costs and provides positive cashflow. Compare similar properties in the area to get a realistic idea of what weekly rent the property can command.
Compliance and Risk
All rental properties in New Zealand must meet legal requirements, including the Healthy Homes Standards. A good rental is one that meets compliance obligations without requiring large or ongoing upgrades.
Also look out for hidden costs. Older properties may need more repairs, and some homes can have risks like water ingress or poor insulation that affect tenant satisfaction and legal liability.
Long Term Performance
What tenant demand is like now matters, but so does the outlook. Areas with steady population growth, infrastructure investment, or zoning changes may offer more stability and potential over time.
The best rental properties are not just about short term returns. They are the ones that stay in demand, are easy to manage, and allow you to make decisions based on your goals, not constant emergencies or tenant churn.
Final Thoughts
What makes a property a good rental is not the kitchen benchtop or the street appeal. It is whether the property performs well as a long term investment.
It should be easy to rent, reasonably priced to maintain, and attractive to the types of tenants common in the area. When the right property is matched with good management, the result is a strong, low stress addition to any portfolio.
Comments